Wednesday 5 June 2019

ELECT OR ELITE?

Recently  an Irish newspaper editorial ended with the words, ...." When  politics fails we must fall back on democracy.....". It was referring to the political chaos resulting from Brexit. 

We Oldies  remember that  within our lifetime the sentence,  "When  politics fails...."   did not end up with ...."we must fall back on democracy.....".   It ended with a word that begins with the letter D right enough but wasn't democracy.  For  millions of our fellow Europeans the choice after politics failed was  trying to democratise family-run Monarchies ( to whom we were graciously allowed to appoint advisors once every few years ) or sliding into a single party Dictatorship. Our Europe was and still is  a slow, unwilling, recent and unsteady convert  to  modern Democracy. 

As Maurice Chevalier might  have sung , "Yes, We Oldies remember it well".

We  should be in mortal fear of losing what democracy we have in Europe. At very least remembering Hilaire Belloc's famous advice to children running into unforeseen and unusual dangers :  "Always keep a hold on Nurse, for fear of  catching something worse".

We have had a lot of elections in the past few years and yet we have had a  lot of national and international chaos too. So it's only natural that  some commentators and voters and even editorial writers might fall into a  certain unhappy train of thought during  election times, a train of thought that goes like this  :

At Election  I

I'll vote for Soanso - right one to get the job done, good candidate, good party....

Next election

I'll never vote for that one again, promised a lot, didn't get....Still vote for the party though ....

Election after that :

I'll vote for that party no more , how did it get so little  done  ..........lazy divils ....this time my vote goes right , left and centre, what difference ?

Next :

Political parties are a waste of money.  Don't want to bother with any of them,  every one of them's  just as bad as the other..........

Next election

No, I'm   not voting any more ....not for any party,  they're all the same , do nothings.   I'm fed up with politics ...politics didn't work here for years , doesn't work now, won't ever, probably never did.....what we need is strong government, not a collection of  parties arguing , all full of people arguing , one strong party that's what we need,  knows what we need without us having to ask again and again , organises the business of government efficiently, doesn't need winning elections to get it . Firm strong government, that's what we need , you known how it is , when politics fails we need . ......what was that bit from the newspaper editorial just last week....when politics fails, it said, what did it say we needed ....Democracy ....but is that  what's coming at us down the line , from America, China, restless Europe ......Trump, moguls , merchants who bring their idea of democracy packaged along with them - pret a manger - instead of letting us work out, stage by painful stage, in our own, slow, ponderous way, our own democracy and what it means ? Democracy created by us through trial and failure as well as trial and success.  The way democracy has to be created and we can make it work.....

For us Oldies, these  can be chilling but at the same time challenging thoughts.  If we despair of our politics and abandon our attempts to democratise  it - not just hope for some heavyweights to come along and control or deform it for us , what can you see coming at us through the chaos ? Some of the politics in America and elsewhere is so  like what happened in Europe all those years ago when millions of people did not for a moment suspect what was going to hit them, when politics would lose its  soul in the hope of gaining the whole world . When the cry ,  " We need strong  government ... "  added the fatal words   "...at all costs "  and millions of marching crowds echoed it through the streets.

Don't let politics  ever again descend into  such a struggle to dominate  each other,  pretending it is democracy.  Politics that does not enrich everyone  can never be democracy. 

So let's make it  a constant effort  to enrich - and then share - each other's  ability to create a world worthy of the world's  dignity and worthy of our own.

Democracy by trial and error, by trial and success. Our trial and error, our trial and success.  We create our own democracy, we don't try to catch whatever is packaged and thrown at us.

 So, goodwill to all candidates, the successful and  the defeated in our elections. We listen and learn from both of you. We need all of you.....

No comments:

Post a Comment